In this TED Talk, social psychologist Tessa West discusses the intricate dynamics of awkward social interactions, delving into why we often become overly nice and generic when we feel anxious or uncomfortable. With over 20 years of experience studying uncomfortable social interactions, she explores how these moments affect us and how we can navigate them more effectively.
Understanding Social Awkwardness
Tessa West begins by addressing a common experience: the anxiety and discomfort that arise during social interactions. Whether it’s meeting a new roommate, negotiating at work, or providing feedback to a boss or a patient, these situations often trigger physiological responses like increased heart rate and sweaty palms. She explains that our reactions in these moments can be categorized into three main areas:
- Verbal Communication: The words we choose, how friendly we are, and how we give feedback.
- Nonverbal Behaviors: Actions like fidgeting, avoiding eye contact, and tone of voice.
- Physiological Responses: Heart rate, blood pressure, and other stress indicators that are beyond our conscious control.
The Study of Social Interactions
To understand these interactions, Tessa conducts experiments where participants engage in various social scenarios, such as negotiations or giving feedback. These experiments reveal that within seconds of an interaction, people begin to exhibit stress responses. Common behaviors include fidgeting, avoiding eye contact, and physical distancing. For instance, in doctor-patient interactions, anxious doctors are more likely to look at charts or computer screens instead of making eye contact with patients.
The Phenomenon of “Anxious Niceness”
One of the key concepts Tessa West explores is “anxious niceness,” where people, in their discomfort, tend to be overly nice and complimentary in a generic way. This often happens in negotiations, where even the winners hesitate to provide constructive criticism to the losers. Instead, they offer vague compliments, which do little to help the other party improve.
Impact on Marginalized Groups
Tessa West highlights a concerning finding: people who frequently receive this type of anxious niceness are often racial minorities or disadvantaged groups. These individuals become more attuned to the nonverbal cues of anxiety from their counterparts, which can lead to physiological stress synchronization. This means that the stress of the person giving feedback can be “caught” by the receiver, potentially harming their well-being over time.
The Problem with Generic Feedback
Generic positive feedback, while seemingly harmless, can be detrimental. It can lead to:
- Misleading Performance Evaluations: Without specific feedback, individuals struggle to understand what they need to improve.
- Hindered Professional Growth: Lack of constructive criticism makes it hard for people to advance in their careers.
- Damaged Reputations: When vague, positive feedback is all that is offered, it can make others question the credibility of the recommender and the capabilities of the person being recommended.
Moving Towards Honest and Useful Feedback
Tessa suggests practical strategies for providing more effective feedback:
- Assess the Feedback Culture: Recognize that not everyone prefers overly nice feedback. Many people find it unhelpful and disengaging.
- Frame Feedback Constructively: Instead of asking if someone wants nice or honest feedback, offer feedback on specific dimensions, such as general versus specific behaviors or actions to continue versus actions to stop.
- Be Specific and Replace Negative Behaviors: When providing critical feedback, specify what the person should stop doing and suggest alternative behaviors.
Starting Small and Neutral
To change a culture of anxious niceness, begin with neutral, non-threatening feedback topics. This can help create a more honest and constructive feedback environment without overwhelming individuals with harsh criticism.
Key Takeaways:
- Recognize and Address Anxious Niceness: Be aware of when you’re being overly nice due to discomfort and strive to provide more genuine and constructive feedback.
- Be Specific in Your Feedback: Avoid vague compliments and criticisms. Provide clear, actionable suggestions for improvement.
- Understand the Impact on Marginalized Groups: Be mindful that your stress and anxiety can affect others, especially those from disadvantaged backgrounds.
- Promote a Culture of Constructive Feedback: Encourage an environment where honest and useful feedback is valued over superficial niceness.
By implementing these strategies, we can transform awkward social interactions into opportunities for genuine connection and personal growth. Tessa West’s insights remind us that authenticity and clarity in communication are key to building better relationships, both personally and professionally.
You Might Also Like:
- Discover Your Next Great Read: New York Times Best-Selling Books
- 7 Must-Read Books Before Turning 25
- Crack the Code to Wealth: “The Algebra of Wealth” by Scott Galloway
- Discovering True Wealth in The Book ‘The Wealth Money Cannot Buy’ by Robin Sharma (Book Summary)
- Book Summary: Just the Good Stuff by Jim VandeHei – Redefining Success
- 7 Must-Read Books for Money Management